Don’t Buy Erewhon Hoodies

If you want value for money and top quality, don’t buy clothes from Erewhon’s new clothing line, even if they look nice.

Courtesy of Erewhon
Erewhon Winter Collection. Courtesy of Erewhon

You don’t shop at Erewhon because you need to, it’s your closest store, or it has the best price for what you’re looking for — because it almost certainly doesn’t.

The supermarket chain — named after the 19th-century novel by Samuel Butler — is beloved both for the quality of its produce but also for the image it projects and the feeling of its settings. To shop at Erewhon, you are an Erewhon person who drinks Erewhon smoothies, showing that not only do you care about your health, but you have the income to splash on it.

Unsurprisingly, this brand loyalty and ethos has allowed them to expand their range and collaborations in a way that no other supermarket chain can, inside and outside of their usual product categories.

They’ve been making collaborative smoothies with figures like Marianna Hewitt and Hailey Beiber — which sell for $17 each — but also had a collaborative line of Balenciaga, including T-shirts, tote bags, caps, aprons ranging between $425 and $1,150. Oh, and an all-black smoothie.

It’s only fitting then that they’ve now branched out into their own in-house fashion line, with a capsule collection of hoodies, sweaters, sweatpants, tote bags, caps, bags, and socks, available initially to their members, and now to the general public, starting last Friday. The colors are lovely — the highlights being a bright pastel orange and grape purple — and I’m sure the 100 percent cotton is very nice.

Only make no mistake: you’re paying a premium for what are almost undoubtedly screen-printed blanks, albeit high-quality ones, which you can otherwise buy elsewhere, unbranded, for far cheaper. The Erewhon hoodie costs $185; a Velour Garments 600 GSM hoodie, available in a far wider range of colors, also out of 100 percent cotton, is $78.

There are far cheaper blanks available out there, but Velour comes readily to mind, and I have bought their product myself, as they offer a designer feel for non-designer prices. And yes, those are 100 percent cotton — which doesn’t mean much anyway, given the variety of cotton available and the quality differences between them.

Again, the prices on the Erewhon range aren’t terrible — certainly compared to $17 smoothies — with $150 sweatpants, $185 hoodies, $45 hats, and $138 tote bags falling in line with the prices of those products from premium brands like Aime Leon Dore, Kith, and its competitors. Yet those will undoubtedly have better quality, and I, for one, wouldn’t want to walk around marketing a supermarket.

In that way, Erewhon’s clothes are like their food; available elsewhere, at far better prices, but if you want their logo and the distinct Erewhon experience, you’re probably happy to pay the premium. And if you don’t get the love for the brand, then these aren’t going to make much sense to you either.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use