Treating With Sinwar?

Why is the Democratic administration in such an all-fired rush for a ceasefire in Gaza. Are they going to treat, even indirectly, with the architect of October 7?

AP/Adel Hana, File
Hamas leader Yehya Sinwar at his office at Gaza City, April 13, 2022. AP/Adel Hana, File

The pressure from the Biden-Harris camp for a ceasefire in Gaza is shocking, coming as it does as Israel appears to be closing in on the architect of October 7, Yahya Sinwar. By putting the squeeze on the Jewish state, the Biden-Harris administration appears intent on snatching a defeat of Israel from the jaws of victory. Their sense that Hamas is entitled to a seat at the table is preposterous — especially because the terrorists have no interest in pulling up a chair.

Ms. Harris and President Biden appear to have their eyes on an August 15 parley meant to hammer out an agreement. Prime Minister Netanyahu promises that Israel will send a delegation to the talks, though he is playing the Jewish state’s cards close to the vest. Why shouldn’t he? Hamas on Sunday announced that it would not attend. America is forcing Israel to negotiate against itself, just when it has Mr. Sinwar on the ropes.  

Meanwhile, Vice President Harris, buoyed by polls, declared at a rally on Saturday after Israel struck a Hamas command center embedded in a school that “yet again, far too many civilians have been killed. We need a hostage deal, and we need a cease-fire. The deal needs to get done, and it needs to get done now.” Set aside Hamas’s disregard for the president’s plan. Israel has a multi-party democracy working on the question of a deal. 

“There is no further time to waste nor excuses from any party for further delay,” is the language of a bull issued by America’s leaders and those of Qatar and Egypt. Also aboard seems to be Iran, whose mission to the United Nations is for “establishing a durable ceasefire in Gaza and the withdrawal of the occupiers.” What is the issue that brings that combination of leaders together? Why are they in such an all-fired the rush?

Hamas could calculate, as our Benny Avni observes, that despite its deteriorating position — Mr. Sinwar was recently promoted after Hamas chief Ismail Haniyeh was assassinated at Tehran  — the Americans are intent on foisting the same deal on Israel as before. Mr. Sinwar’s camarilla, though, is decimated, and the IDF appear to be redoubling their efforts at Khan Younis. This could be an indication that they are closing in on Mr. Sinwar’s lair. 

That brings us back to the question of whether the Biden-Harris administration is going to treat with Mr. Sinwar even as Israel’s armed forces work to deliver to him his desserts. The broader point is that is it difficult to see as anything but a victory for Hamas the imposition on the Jewish state of a deal that spares Mr. Sinwar — and Iran. Mr. Biden sought to deter Israel before, at Rafah. The Jewish state persisted, and gains were achieved.

It is those gains — and others throughout Gaza — that Mr. Netanyahu contends would bring Mr. Sinwar to the negotiating table. That approach appears to have been vindicated. Ms. Harris’s view from the stump, though, has sight lines only for her party’s left flank. She hopes to appease it sufficiently to win them to her bid for the White House. Israel, after a year of war, would be within its rights to refuse to negotiate any terms save Hamas’ surrender.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use