Police Are Impounding Oakland Teslas To Obtain Video Footage of Crimes Captured by Cars’ Cameras

‘I think this is an indication of more of what we’ll see as cameras proliferate,’ one observer tells the Sun, as law enforcement increasingly relies on third-party devices to fight crime.

Courtesy Tesla

Oakland, California police officers are reportedly increasingly relying on Teslas — and even obtaining court orders to tow them — to obtain video footage of crimes that happen near where the cars are parked. 

Police in the Oakland area are “frequently” looking to Teslas to provide video footage from its expansive outer camera system, a San Francisco Chronicle report found.

And although the police often obtain an owner’s permission to gather the footage, they are now seeking search warrants to tow the Teslas into evidence — with the aim of pursuing as many leads as possible in cases when the car owners aren’t around. 

Law enforcement points to Tesla’s unique “Sentry Mode,” which according to Tesla’s website, keeps the vehicle’s cameras and sensors “powered on and ready to record suspicious activity” even when the car is locked and in park mode. 

“I know that Tesla vehicles contain external surveillance cameras in order to protect their drivers from theft and/or liability in accidents,” one officer, Kevin Godchaux, wrote in one search warrant affidavit, the Chronicle reports.

He was seeking to view footage on a Tesla that was parked at a La Quinta Inn near where a man was found with gunshot and stab wounds, believing that the car’s cameras may have captured the potential homicide.

“I respectfully request,” the officer wrote, “that a warrant is authorized to seize this vehicle from the La Quinta Inn parking lot so this vehicle’s surveillance footage may be searched via an additional search warrant at a secure location.”

Teslas’ unique camera systems — which are not always activated — could provide police with helpful tools when they happen to be parked near a crime scene, but taking the cars into evidence unbeknownst to the owner comes with challenges. 

In addition to the car towings being an “inconvenience” to car owners, a legal fellow at the Cato Institute, Brent Skorup, tells the Sun, there could be some “constitutional complaints” as car owners have “their property removed at least temporarily from their possessions.”

The Tesla video footage that is used by police could also be symbolic of a growing surveillance state as law enforcement increasingly relies on third party devices to fight crime. 

“I think this is an indication of more of what we’ll see as cameras proliferate,” Mr. Skorup says, adding that a similar pattern has emerged with doorbell cameras.

“Police are using, you know, typically asking a homeowner or a convenience store or something to use their video, but sometimes they do seize it,” he said.

“Much like doorbell cams spread rapidly and police are using it, as these car cams proliferate,” he added, “I would expect police to use this in their investigations.”

The Oakland Police Department’s press contact was not reachable for comment, and Tesla did not immediately respond to a request for comment.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use