Met Is Seeking Dialogue on ‘Hot Pot’
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.
The Metropolitan Museum is facing threats from Italian authorities who claim that the Euphronios Krater, a fifth century B.C.E. vase that the museum acquired in 1971, was looted. The provenance of the work has long been the subject of controversy. But Italian prosecutors say that evidence currently being used to prosecute a former curator of the J. Paul Getty Museum could also prove that the vase was exported illegally.
In a series of recent articles, the Los Angeles Times has outlined how a case recently brought in Italy against the curator, Marion True, and an American art dealer, Robert Hecht Jr., for allegedly conspiring to acquire looted antiquities may affect other American museums. Mr. Hecht is the dealer who sold the Met the vase.
Prosecutors have used Polaroid photos seized in 1995 from convicted dealer Giacomo Medici to call into question 42 works currently in Getty’s collection. Similar Polaroids seem to link eight objects to the Met, according to the Times.
Other museums with works the Italian authorities are questioning include the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, the Princeton University Art Museum, the Toledo Museum of Art, and the Minneapolis Institute of Arts.
Italian authorities have not contacted the Met regarding the new evidence, and museum officials refused to comment on the prosecution of Ms. True or to elaborate beyond a statement saying that in February it contacted the Italian Ministry of Culture “requesting a full discussion of works in the Metropolitan’s collection that were the subject of the Ministry’s concern.” The museum said it has “reiterated its request for a meeting,” but one has not yet been scheduled.
The same vase was the subject of an investigation in the late 1970s by the office of the Manhattan district attorney, Robert Morgenthau. Reached by phone late last evening, Mr. Morgenthau would not comment on the matter.
Accounts of how the museum came to acquire the vase are contradictory. Evidence from Mr. Hecht’s diary, seized in 2001, seems to indicate that he bought the Euphronius Krater in 1971 from Medici. But Mr. Hecht has denied his own account.
Thomas Hoving, the director of the museum when it purchased the work, long believed Mr. Hecht’s account of how he obtained the vase, but has since come to believe it was, as he famously put it, a “hot pot.” Nevertheless, in a long account of the controversies written for the artnet Web site last year, he concluded: “Should it go back to Italy? Hell, no. Despite our suspicions, we bought it in good faith and it arrived legally to U.S. customs.”