Comrade Kamala: Her Economic Plan Will Never Work

She wants government planners to run the economy — and your life — while Trump wants you to keep more of what you earn.

AP/Mike Stewart
Vice President Harris at Raleigh, North Carolina, August 16, 2024. AP/Mike Stewart

Price controls and a government takeover of the economy never works. 

No matter whether you’re Josef Stalin, Fidel Castro, Nicolás Maduro, Richard Nixon, or Kamala Harris — it will never work. And no one is going to take it seriously.

Democratic economists are attacking it. The Washington Post is attacking it. 

Early estimates of the cost of Vice President Harris’s plan are already running toward $2 trillion. Which of course means more deficit spending and more inflation.

The big items so far: the $3,600 kiddie credit that costs about $1 trillion over ten years, the newborn child credit — another $100 billion, and a $25,000 home mortgage subsidy would be about $250 billion. And various other tax credits and debt cancellations yet to be priced out.

There are new tax credits for Obamacare, another bump-up in the earned income tax credit, some kind of debt cancellation for health care costs, and of course let’s not forget the unconstitutional student loan cancellations. The details of all that stuff are so far unknown.

And of course the headline grabber — which is the first ever federal ban on “price gouging” on food and groceries — is really just price controls dressed up as … price controls.

In other words, to quote Churchill, a sheep in sheep’s clothing.

And President Trump’s got it right, as well, explaining: “Now, Kamala is reportedly proposing communist price control.”  

He continues: “But, they don’t work. They actually have the exact opposite impact and effect, but it leads to food shortages, rationing, hunger, dramatically more inflation.” 

Trump concludes: “We call it the Maduro plan. Like something straight out of Venezuela, the Soviet Union.” There you go.

For one thing, no one’s ever proven price gouging,  even though the Bidens have tried for over three-and-a-half years. No one even knows what it is

And a study by the San Francisco Fed ruled it out.

What the Kamala Harris Democrats don’t understand is that rising prices don’t cause inflation — inflation causes rising prices. And inflation is too much money chasing too few goods. All of which devalues the money in your wallets and pocketbooks.

This whole baloney about price gouging and excess profits, and corporate greed, is the longtime hallmark of the distant far left, and it pops up every now and then, is laughed out of the room, and we don’t hear about it for a long while.

Prediction: that’s gonna happen again, this time around.

Oh, by the way, profit margins for grocers like Kroger, Albertsons, Walmart, Costco — average 1.2 percent.

And as far as those so-called predatory meat, beef, and poultry companies — their margins are 4.7 percent. Very low.

So, both groceries and beef are well below the 8.5 percent profit margins of all American companies.

And, by the way, high flying tech companies have huge profit margins: Apple 25 percent, Meta and Microsoft 34 percent, Nvidia 53  percent.

So far, though, Ms. Harris isn’t going after them.

She talks about clear rules of the road, but doesn’t offer up any.

New authority for the Federal Trade Commission, which is a very scary thought.

Basically apart from the headline price controls equals socialism, the whole rest of her program is top-down big government control of the economy.

Government to do this, government to do that. Government to cancel loans, government to boss around Wall Street.

By the way, the $25,000 down payment handout for first-time homeowners… Well, guess what? Every homeowner will raise their selling price by $25,000 to equalize the market.

And guess what else? Spending a couple trillion more dollars means borrowing more, debt-creating more, which probably means even higher mortgage rates.

Which will probably still leave the dream of home ownership out of reach of Gen Z’ers.

And, hidden up her sleeve, is a gigantic tax increase aimed at financing all this social spending and central planning.

And there she goes again, criticizing the Trump tax cuts with a pack of untruths, like the usual fare offered up by President Biden about how only rich people and big corporations benefited and never pay their fair share.

In today’s Wall Street Journal editorial — entitled: “How the Biden-Harris economy left most Americans behind,” with the subhead: “A government spending boom fueled inflation that has crushed real average incomes” — they talk about $6 trillion in new Biden-Harris deficits, twice as much as Trump.

And the highest inflation in over four decades. Prices increased by 20 percent since January 2021, compared to only 7.8 percent during the Trump years.

Inflation adjusted average weekly earnings down 3.9 percent under Biden-Harris, compared to an increase of 2.6 percent during Trump’s first three years.

They could have added that under Trump’s tax cuts, poverty rates fell, minority unemployment dropped to record low rates, and the biggest gainers in the income scale were middle and lower income wage earners, not the rich.

Ms. Harris is also spewing untruths about Trump tariffs that as yet don’t even exist — looks like he prefers reciprocity, a better approach than outright protectionism.

Plus, even with tariffs, Trump would offset that with tax cuts at home that would provide strong incentives to work and invest.

She accuses Trump of getting rid of Obamacare, but that’s not his policy; instead, in his 2017 tax cut bill, he repealed the unpopular individual mandate.

Step back from all this for a moment, though.

Basically, Kamala Harris wants government central planners to run the economy — and your life.

Trump wants you to keep more of what you earn, in a competitive free enterprise economy.

Ms. Harris is a prescription for economic decline.

Trump is prescribing economic resurgence and growth.

I’m betting on the growth guy.

From Mr. Kudlow’s broadcast on Fox Business Network.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use