Pakistan Urges NATO To Accept Taliban Rule in Afghanistan
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.
ISLAMABAD, PAKISTAN — Senior Pakistani officials are urging NATO countries to accept the Taliban and work toward a new coalition government in Kabul that might exclude President Karzai of Afghanistan.
Pakistan’s foreign minister, Khurshid Kasuri, has said in private briefings to foreign ministers of some NATO member states that the Taliban are winning the war in Afghanistan and that NATO is bound to fail. He has advised against sending more troops.
Western ministers have been stunned. “Kasuri is basically asking NATO to surrender and to negotiate with the Taliban,” one Western official who met the minister recently said.
The remarks were made on the eve of NATO’s critical summit in Latvia. The British general and NATO’s force commander in Afghanistan, Lieutenant General David Richards, and its chief diplomat there, the Dutch ambassador Daan Everts, have spent five days in the Pakistani capital, Islamabad, urging the Pakistani military to do more to reign in the Taliban. But they have received mixed messages.
Mr. Karzai has long insisted that the Taliban sanctuaries and logistics bases are in Pakistan while the Supreme Commander of NATO, General James Jones, told the U.S. Congress in September that the Taliban leadership is headquartered in the Pakistani city of Quetta.
The governor of the volatile Northwest Frontier Province, Lieutenant General Ali Mohammed Jan Orakzai, has stated publicly that America, Britain, and NATO have already failed in Afghanistan.”Either it is a lack of understanding or it is a lack of courage to admit their failures,” he said recently.
General Orakzai insists that the Taliban represent the Pashtun population, Afghanistan’s largest and Pakistan’s second largest ethnic group, and that they now lead a “national resistance” movement to throw out Western occupation forces as there is in Iraq.
But his comments have deeply angered many Pakistani and Afghan Pashtuns, who consider the Taliban as pariahs and a negation of Pashtun values. General Orakzai is the mastermind of “peace deals” between the army and the heavily Talibanized Pashtun tribes on the Pakistani side of the border, but these agreements have failed because they continue to allow the Taliban to attack NATO forces inside Afghanistan and leave the Taliban in place, free to run a mini-Islamic state.
General Orakzai is expected to urge the British Army to strike similar deals in Helmand province. Meanwhile, aides to President Musharraf of Pakistan say he has virtually “given up” on Mr. Karzai and is awaiting a change of face in Kabul before he offers more help.
Many Afghans fear that Pakistan is deliberately trying to undermine Mr. Karzai and NATO’s commitment to his government in an attempt to reinstall its Taliban proxies in Kabul — almost certainly leading to all-out civil war and possible partition of the country.
To progress in Riga, NATO will have to enlist American support to call Pakistan’s bluff, put pressure on Islamabad to hand over the Taliban leadership, and put more troops in to fight the insurgency while persuading Mr. Karzai to become more pro-active.