Communist China Crackdown on Hong Kong Dissent Reverberates on Taiwan
The message is that China will look for any pretext to assert its will against those daring to defy its authoritarian rule.
The arrests, trials, and imprisonment of those who led the protests at Hong Kong against Chinaâs dictatorial takeover send a frightening message to the 23.6 million citizens of the island state of Taiwan.
The message is that China will look for any pretext to assert its will against those daring to defy its authoritarian rule â as itâs done at Hong Kong, in violation of the agreement with Britain under which the former colony was to remain self-governing for 50 years after its formal takeover by China in 1997.
The English-language Global Times, an offshoot of the paper of the Chinese Communist Party, Peopleâs Daily, labels as âdeterrents to secessionistsâ the saga of arrests, guilty pleas, and sentences imposed on âdozens of anti-China figures.â
The crackdown on independent voices in Hong Kong, repressing heroic protests against edicts emanating from Beijing, comes as China conducts nonstop military exercises in the Taiwan Strait. âIt would be much worse here than in Hong Kong,â a young Taiwanese told me. âThey would arrest thousands of people. They would have concentration camps on the island.â
Like most Taiwanese, he seemed confident the island would remain free as long as its leaders and people stood firm against mainland demands and were sure of the commitment of the United States and other countries to guarantee defense. Inevitably, though, Chinaâs rising pressure arouses concern if not fear.
China is expected to stoke concerns in the run-up to the congress of the ruling Chinese Communist Party at Beijing in November. No doubt President Xi will win a third five-year term, but heâs sure to keep up the pressure on Taiwan as he flexes his muscles as a strongman while distracting attention from economic pressures at home.
âWe have to be wary,â Chieng Chung, of the Association of Strategic Foresight in Taipei, said. Tension will focus, he told Taiwanâs Central News Agency, on the median line that historically has divided the 100-mile-wide Taiwan Strait. Taiwan, he said, must âfind ways to stop the Chinese military from crossing the line.â
That kind of basic defense appears impossible considering the impunity with which Chinese warships encircled Taiwan during visits led by Speaker Pelosi and then Senator Markey, both prominent Democrats accompanied by coteries of Democratic colleagues, on missions seen by the Chinese as having the blessing of President Biden.
True, the Chinese might ask, Mr. Biden made a show of trying to talk Mrs. Pelosi out of going, but didnât she and her entourage, including five other members of Congress, travel on a luxury U.S. Air Force passenger plane with the words âUnited States of Americaâ proudly emblazoned on the sides? Werenât Secret Service agents on board just to make sure they got there and back safe and sound?
Chinese warships were conducting drills in the Taiwan Strait, playing their game of intimidation, when yet another American delegation, this one led by Indianaâs Republican governor, Eric Holcomb, with his commerce secretary in tow, showed up Sunday looking for âeconomic developmentâ after Taiwanâs MediaTek said itâs opening shop in Indiana.
Like Mrs. Pelosi and Mr. Markey, Mr. Holcomb met Taiwanâs president, Tsai Ing-wen Tsai, who said Taiwan had confronted âmilitary threats from Chinaâ and âdemocratic allies must stand together.â The Chinese have yet to make a fuss over Mr. Holcombâs visit, but no one thinks Chinaâs about to let up the pressure.
David Chen, with the American consulting firm CENTRA Technology, was reported by the Associated Press as saying âwe are in for a risky period of testing boundaries and finding out who can achieve escalatory dominance across the diplomatic, military and economic domains.â
So far the Chinese game is not having the impact the Chinese might be looking for. âTaiwan braces for sustained Chinese pressure,â said a headline from Taiwanâs Central News Agency, reporting that âthe public mood in Taiwan is mixed.â
The agency cited polls showing 60 percent to 78 percent of respondents âwere not worried about large-scale live-fire military drills launched by Beijingâ after Mrs. Pelosiâs visit. Taiwanâs defense ministry said Chinaâs âsimulated attackâ had been âmet with a shrug by many in a country wearily attuned to Chinese saber-rattling.â
One sticking point is that China and Taiwan, on an official level, have not been talking to one another for six years. Thatâs when Ms. Tsai was elected president for the first time as the candidate of the Democratic Progressive Party. The DPP has called for âindependenceâ for Taiwan as a nation; Ms. Tsai prefers that Taiwan remain in a gray area in which itâs totally self-ruled but not declaring nationhood.
In fact, China and Taiwan need each other. Despite showing off its military superiority, China remains by far Taiwanâs largest trading partner. Taiwan this year is exporting more than $200 billion worth of products, notably semiconductors and other electronic items, to China, including Hong Kong, for a trade surplus of more than $100 billion.
America ranks far behind China in two-way trade with Taiwan, at more than $110 billion expected this year. Washington, worried about its trade deficit of more than $30 billion with Taiwan, is planning trade talks with Taiwan in the fall.
Kurt Campbell, coordinating White House policy in the Indo-Pacific, said the talks would âdeepen our ties with Taiwan,â to which an official with Chinaâs commerce ministry said China âfirmly opposesâ another step toward Taiwan independence.