Tweedy, Browne’s Secrets of Value Investing

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Tweedy, Browne is money management’s equivalent of the Republican cloth coat: nothing flashy, ever dependable, transcending style. It is an organization that was founded in 1920 to deal in thinly traded stocks, and which in the 1950s realized that more money was to be made in owning such typically undervalued shares than in trading them. The firm began to take in outside funds in 1968 and has grown to manage more than $13 billion today.

It did not hurt that one of the firm’s earliest and best clients was Benjamin Graham, co-author in 1934 of the near-biblical “Security Analysis.” Indeed, the company’s early association with Mr. Graham (and proximity — it moved into office space down the hall from the revered investor) led also to a relationship with Walter Schloss, Warren Buffett, and Tom Knapp, who joined the firm in 1957 and spearheaded its entrée into the investment game. These are formidable value bloodlines. Christopher Browne is one of three members of the company’s management committee and son of an early founder. He has recently written “The Little Book of Value Investing,” which lays out the money management disciplines that have been so successful for Tweedy, Browne. In it, he argues the merit of buying “stocks on sale” and answers the obvious question: If value investing is so successful, and so simple, why doesn’t everybody do it? (You’ll have to buy the book.)

I asked him how his firm practices value investing today. He says Tweedy, Browne eschews a top-down approach and instead looks for companies that would meet an updated version of Benjamin Graham’s requirements.

That is, it looks for companies selling at conservative multiples of enterprise value, with good balance sheets and positive cash flow and earnings prospects. In other words, it is looking for the same kinds of stocks that attract private equity players these days. That is a problem, according to Mr. Browne. Because of the gigantic inflow of funds to private equity shops, solid companies that could satisfy Tweedy, Browne’s criteria are being snapped up. Consequently, he and his associates are struggling to find good investment ideas.

That’s one reason the firm closed to new customers in May of last year. The directors agreed that not enough good new ideas were coming off their screens, and they wanted to protect the performance of existing clients. This dedication to clients has paid off; few have ever left the firm, including its first institutional client, FMC Corporation.

Closing to new accounts might, however, be viewed as problematical for Affiliated Managers Group, which bought 70% of the company in 1997. Though one might expect that AMG would be pushing the firm to expand, it instead evidently allows Tweedy, Browne almost total independence. That hands-off approach has been rewarded with a doubling in the value of AMG’s investment, according to Mr. Browne.

Mr. Browne says the firm may reopen if valuations change, but in the meantime the investment teams in New York and London are having to scramble for good ideas. One source is companies that suffer a “surprise” that knocks the stock’s valuation. For instance, Tweedy, Browne was a buyer of insurance giant AIG in the aftermath of the resignation of embattled chairman Maurice Greenberg. The stock is currently selling at $71, but traded near $50 as the drama played out.

Similarly, the firm bought Bausch & Lomb (BOL $49) after the company halted shipments of its contact lens solution. The stock dropped 15% at the time of the announcement and traded lower in subsequent months. After selling above $80 several months before the announcement of possible problems, the issue traded as low at $40. Convinced of the strength of the underlying business, Tweedy, Browne took advantage of the plunge.

Such decisions always appear easy in hindsight, but stepping up takes courage born of conviction. Such conviction has surely been tested in recent years. During the tech boom of the late 1990s, Tweedy, Browne sat out, unconvinced of the business models of the start-up supernovas and repelled by the valuations. It could not have been easy, but astonishingly the firm did not lose accounts and ultimately, of course, emerged a hero.

Since the 1980s the firm has had to go further afield to find value. For instance, valuations in South Korea are depressed by concerns about regional instability. For example, SK Telecom (SKM $26), the country’s leading cell phone business, is selling at about half the multiple of comparable operations around the world. That excites the Tweedy, Browne crowd, which feels that the risks of aggression from North Korea are exaggerated and will ultimately be reduced by China’s ever growing involvement in regional politics. Citing its view that cheaper stocks are to be found overseas, the company in September changed the name of its American Value Fund to the Value Fund and eliminated the requirement to invest 80% of the fund’s assets in America. Today about two-thirds of all assets are in international securities.

The firm’s flagship Global Value Fund earned investors 12.57% annualized over the 10 years ending in September, compared to an average return of 7.93% for Morningstar’s World Stock Funds. For five years the firm also outperformed: 12.48% vs. 11.2%.

Though the company has been adventurous on this front, it has otherwise stuck to its knitting. It is only invested in equities, and it has not chosen to follow many of its competitors into the hedge fund arena. Mr. Browne is clearly comfortable pursuing his value niche, which he describes in his book as “the stress-free route to investment success.” So stress-free, in fact, that retirement is not even on the table. “I am doing what I want to do,” Mr. Browne says.

Tell us again why there aren’t there more value investors?


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use