Recent Editorials

Reader comment on:
Israel's Electric Revolution?

Submitted by Roger Pham, Dec 2, 2007 03:14

Battery replacement for batteries weighing 500-1000 lbs to be done every 100 miles would be highly impractical. So would be the large number of battery-replacing stations required for these operations when the car's driving range is only ~100 miles before requiring battery change. If the battery is made detachable, it should be replaced with an electrical generator set (genset) powered by a small Wankel rotary engine (very compact and powerful) coupled with a small but high power battery module for buffering of power. That way, only a small number of locations where the replacement electrical generator (genset) will need to be stored, and the owner only have to fill up the genset with gasoline when extended driving range is needed.

Most people drive much less than 100 miles each day, more like 40-60 miles, so the BEV (Battery Electric Vehicle) can be charged at home at night. On the rare occasion that they need to exceed the 100-mi driving range, they can rent a gasoline car for the occasion, or rent a replacement genset in place of the detachable battery if the battery is made easily detachable. An ownership club for these gasoline cars and/or gensets, which provide rapid and automated acquisition of these gasoline cars or gensets using only a swipeable membership card can make it very convenient to quickly borrow these cars or gensets on an hourly basis, or daily basis for out-of-town trips. No new infrastructure needs be setup. A supermarket's parking lot is all that would be needed to park these "club cars", for rapid acquisition. You would park your BEV at designated spots with charging sockets, at these supermarkets, then plug in the BEV to juice it up while you acquire a gasoline "club car" with ranges of 350-600 miles between fueling, for extended-distance driving. When your mission is accomplished, you return the "club car" and pick up your charged BEV for the trip home.

Voila...practical BEV utilization without new, or major infrastructure


Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. We reserve the right to reject anything we find objectionable.

Other reader comments on this article

Comment By Date

I have nothing but admiration for the Israelis for taking on such an ambitious endeavor. With advances in batteries and ceramic... [MORE]

Gary Miller

Jan 21, 2008 13:23

This is not the way to go...ripped off by gas stations..now charging stations?? do not think so... Solar recharge as you... [MORE]

r wells

Dec 3, 2007 16:24

gentlemenIsrael's Electric Revolution is nothing new check my web site of the 1990swww.angelfire.com/nj4/streetrag/index3.htmlalso some of the patent listed are dating... [MORE]

Jack Marchand

Dec 11, 2007 22:53

You also might want to consider Apollo Energy System's Tri Polar lead cobalt battery, much less expensive to buy and... [MORE]

William Thompson

Dec 3, 2007 16:04

Battery replacement for batteries weighing 500-1000 lbs to be done every 100 miles would be highly impractical. So would be...

Roger Pham

Dec 2, 2007 03:14

When you can charge up in less than 10-minutes with Altair's Li-Ion batteries? With a proper charging station, which I'm sure... [MORE]

BJD

Nov 30, 2007 13:38

Battery technology is not as good as people think. Altairnano delivers more hype than real accomplishment. Phoenix Motorcar is bust. Agassi... [MORE]

ED

Nov 30, 2007 15:08

There already is a battery known as NiMH which is what's powering all those RAV4 EVs you see in California,... [MORE]

Roy

Nov 30, 2007 15:24

For the Altair battery to take a 10 minute charge, the power of a small electrical substation is required. Agassi's... [MORE]

RP

Nov 30, 2007 17:06

His idea to swap batteries is based on the assumption that it takes at least 3 hours to charge a... [MORE]

EV Enthusiast

Nov 30, 2007 18:41

Why not test market the concept, in larger cities, with rental cars that can replace an expended battery vehicle with... [MORE]

Ken Bond

Nov 13, 2007 13:56

Israel invests a small fraction of its economy on a technology that could stop it from assisting in the funding... [MORE]

matthew veal

Nov 13, 2007 09:41

The naysayers are enamored with paying $100 plus for a barrel of oil ad infinitum. It would seem to me... [MORE]

Paul B. Evans

Nov 13, 2007 07:51

Make the vehicles hybrids with a smaller battery pack and RP's suggested wankel genset, but use ammonia as the fuel... [MORE]

William Thompson

Dec 3, 2007 15:21

Comment on Israel's Electric Revolution?

Name
Email Address
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. The New York Sun reserves the right to reject anything found to be objectionable.

Would You Like to Become a Sustaining Subscriber of the Sun? Sign up now

* Inquire about the Sun Seminars

Sustaining Subscriber Login

Follow The New York Sun

Facebook    Twitter    RSS    Join Mailing List

Buy China Wholesale Products on DHgate.com

For Vegas Show tickets, shop ShowTickets.com

Hamptons Estate Agents

Made-in-China.com

Make sure your dresses are beautiful

Planning an Orlando Vacation? Visit Best of Orlando!